Welcome to Card Game DB
Register now to gain access to all of our features. Once registered and logged in, you will be able to create topics, post replies to existing threads, give reputation to your fellow members, get your own private messenger, post status updates, manage your profile and so much more. If you already have an account, login here - otherwise create an account for free today!
Blogs@ CardGameDB
May 18, 2013: Netrunner in Austin, Texas By Keggy Back to Austin for Netrunner regional #2. After squeaking into the top 8 last time, I was hoping to either get top 2 or blow out and have fun.
The TO took up the score sheets I...
Centerville Tourney Report May 19, 2013 By erocklawell Hey Everyone!!
This is my first tournament break down, but second tournament, and I felt the need to record the games I've played. I may do a report on my first tour...
May 11, 2013: A Game of Thrones Regional in Austin, Texas By Keggy Round three of regionals in Austin. I'm gonna apologize in advance for many, many memory gaps.
Pre-Tournament Report
This was gonna be my first Thrones tourney, and I was...
Ottawa Regional By darknoj So my second regional of the session was a bit smaller then the first. I think the lower turn out was due to the extremely high cost to attend (35 to get into the con, 10 for th...
Stark City of Shadows (Winter Burn) By agktmte So I'd like to start off by posting a deck list I made for a "creative deck night" we had a few weeks back at the Team Covenant store in Tulsa, OK. I had previously...
Laval Regional By darknoj So I went to my first regional of the year last weekend. Thirteen players showed up at BD Cosmos in Laval Quebec to play AGoT. I had prepared three different decks for the event...
Game of Thrones Regionals 2013 By 14Shirt Well I took the plunge and entered my first-ever regionals for GoT (first-ever card tournament of any kind, actually). I took a Stark Siege army deck I was having some fun with...
April 20, 2013: Netrunner Regional in Austin, Texas By Keggy Another week, another regional. I enjoyed my Star Wars tournament at Mothership Games in Austin the week before, and looked forward to going back.
Pre-Tournament Report
I was...
April 13, 2013: Star Wars Regional in Austin, Texas By Keggy Maybe I shouldn't wait two weeks to write up tourney reports. Oh, well.
Pre-Tournament Report
So, this was my first official tournament for any LCG. We had hosted a few...
Tourney Report: UK Huddersfield Regional 2013 By JCWamma With regional season back upon us I can resume my favourite part of this game - talking for too long about my competitive experiences and expecting people to pay attention!...
Thank you SO MUCH for the discussion about Kat's deck and what changes you'd make. As a new player, it was invaluable to hear a breakdown of each card and the role it plays in a deck, and whether it should stay or go in the context of what the deck is trying to accomplish. When I see decks posted here and elsewhere, I'm still at the stage where I have no idea what I'm looking at, so the why-a-deck-works-the-way-it-does analysis in its entirety did more for me than just about anything else so far I've read or heard so far. The podcast will bear a repeat listen so I can go through each card to get an idea of what I should be trying to do.
If this has been done with past podcasts (card-by-card deck analysis), then I definitely need to catch up on those. If not, I think it makes for a great format and hopefully something we'll see more of in the future.
Glad you liked it! If you're looking for similarly detailed looks at decks, I'd suggest both Groupthink episodes where we build decks up from scratch. Then we even played a match between the two decks, so all told, it's a pretty nifty trio, I think. In fact, Brett was just saying last night that we need to make that a semi-regular thing every few months, so look forward to more in that vein.
That would be awesome - will definitely go back and give a listen to the Groupthink eps. There are too many times when I look at a winning deck and wonder why certain cards are even there. There are combinations and rules "advantages" that I've found I tend to misunderstand.
I want to ring in on the "Wilding" issue raised. I think I understand Greg's issue. He probably felt it was a simple typo and it should just be ignored because the character is clearly a "Wildling". I understand that it would be frustrating for him for such a clear typo to not be ignored. That is probably why he decided to not play the deck. Not because the card was a lynch pin bit probably out of some weird moral issue Greg had with your ruling.
After considering his side and yours I would also agree with your decision. However, if I am playing with meta or just a casual game I would say it is up to us to let it slide. In a tourney setting though you have to go with printed rules.
Just my opinion.
4 Comments
Deroche
Apr 14 2012 01:25 AM
If this has been done with past podcasts (card-by-card deck analysis), then I definitely need to catch up on those. If not, I think it makes for a great format and hopefully something we'll see more of in the future.
Again, much appreciated.
Kennon
Apr 15 2012 02:32 PM
doulos2k
Apr 17 2012 07:27 PM
BARF
Apr 21 2012 02:03 PM
After considering his side and yours I would also agree with your decision. However, if I am playing with meta or just a casual game I would say it is up to us to let it slide. In a tourney setting though you have to go with printed rules.
Just my opinion.