5 replies to this topic

[Ulric]

Total Cards (60)

House (1)
Neutral Faction (IG) x1

Agenda (1)
The Brotherhood Without Banners (RoR) x1

Plot (7)
Wildfire Assault (Core) x1
Take Them by Surprise (LoW) x1
Relentless Persecution (DB) x1
Men of Duty (AHM) x1
Focused Offense (QoD) x1
Feast or Famine (KotStorm) x1
Retaliation! (ASoSilence) x1

Character (30)
Anguy the Archer (DB) x2
Beric Dondarrion (IG) x3
Gendry (FF) x3
Ghost of High Heart (WLL) x3
The Mad Huntsman (ASoSilence) x3
Thoros of Myr (RoR) x3
Tom Sevenstrings (RoR) x2
Orphaned Recruit (OSaS) x3
Lady of the Leaves (FF) x3
Harwin (FF) x2
Lem Lemoncloak (MotM) x2
Maester Aemon (Core) x1

Location (16)
Hollow Hill (ASoSilence) x2
River Row (QoD) x1
Shadowblack Lane (Core) x1
Street of Sisters (Core) x1
Street of Steel (Core) x1
The Kingsroad 23 (FaI) x3
The Kingsroad 29 (FaI) x3
Flea Bottom (TGM) x1
Isle of Faces (APS) x3

Attachment (11)
Condemned (TBC) x3
Flaming Sword (DB) x3
Milk of the Poppy (Core) x2
Bastard (LotR) x3

Event (3)
Whispers from the Hill (ASoSilence) x3

ok this is a nasty deck i planing to make. i believe that it lacks of event cards but i cant find anything else for this deck.what's your thoughts?

Click here to view the deck

[LorasTyrell]

ok this is a nasty deck i planing to make. i believe that it lacks of event cards but i cant find anything else for this deck.what's your thoughts?

Click here to view the deck

I noticed you have only Neutral Cards, that way you won't really exploit the Whole benefit of using the neutral faction, since you can play neutrals in any house. Imo at the moment the bets house to run Brotherhood is Martell, since you can have access to Calls It Thinking in case Ygritte tries and stole your Beric, plus you have great draw with Flea Bottom Scavenger. You could run Burning on The Sands as your retricted, or Venomous Blade, to instantly kill Ygritte in case you don't have your Calls It Thinking. Also Nightmares is a pain in the ass and i recommend 3xPaper Shield. Besides that, you are good to go If you want to stay neutral, you could still add some out of house cards such as the aforementioned Scavengers or other great characters such as Stannis Baratheon (VM) or whatever you like most... but you wouldn't be able to access house specific events of course

[jme]

I believe you're only allowed 3 copies total of The Kingsroad - you can mix the summer & winter versions, but since they have the same title, you're limited to 3.

Looks like fun! I wish there was a reason to run a neutral faction out of Neutral Faction.

[Ulric]

thanks guys

[Zulla]

it seems to me you are all over the place with the deck. Find out what you want the deck to do. They could benefit greatly if you narrowed down the focus. For example I played a guy who ran his out of martell (as well as me). A big reason was flea bottom scavanger and Dorne location that lowers cost of a certain trait. And Maester Aemon, I'm looking through your list and see no reason for him to be in there. He saves nights watch characters right? Also, if you pick a faction, you can benefit from the income of that house (water garden/martell etc.) as well as event cards. All that being said, get a theme for the deck and get at it. Returning cards to hands, blanking text boxes, joust, kneeling etc. Thanks for letting me comment.

[Asklepios]

Will come back to the specific deck later, but one thing I note with Brotherhood Neutral, is that there is a lot really good neutral faction stuff going on this cycle.

 

Any neutral deck right now I think should have 3 x In The Hands of the Qohorik, 1 Septon Utt, 1 Shagwell, 2-3 Brave Companions, and in view of the above cards, should consider Calling The Banners.

 

Thats just for neutral decks in general, and right now I'm not entirely sure that neutral and Brotherhood go well together, even if most Brotherhood characters are neutral.

 

The opportunity cost is too high:

- If you're running Brotherhood, you're missing the chance to take advantage of a House.

- If you're running Neutral, you're missing the chance to run TLV or Neutral No Agenda.

 

Still, there may be Neutral Brotherhood possibilities. Currently messing around on octgn to see if its possible, but an hour of card-poking yesterday didn't leave me with anything I was happy with.